I was not at Occupy Oakland. I have not gone to Occupy Oakland. There, now if you wish to dismiss me you can do so upfront and not bother reading the rest of this. I was not there because I have a job. It is not a good job. I work very hard, kill my body, and will probably be physically unable to do this job after age 30. I make okayish money. Enough to live on, but not much more than that. I had to take my car into the shop yesterday and now I will eat rice and beans for a month. I live two people in a one bedroom apartment. That gives you a good idea of what I make. I do have health insurance though. That said, I wouldn’t have been there even if I wasn’t working. If I was jobless, maybe. Though it’s doubtful because I’m scared of even small things, so large things like this are almost too overwhelming for me to comprehend.
I love this city. I hate this city. This is one of the greatest, most terrible places I have ever been. This is home. Really, I don’t have a ton going for me here, but I stay because it is home and home is where I belong. Oakland is my heart. It is the arms that wrap me up at night and tell me I’m too fat the next day. Alright, enough with the inadequate metaphors. You either understand Oakland or you don’t. I’m sure your city is the same in some respect; multiply that by2-10 depending on where you live and you’ll get to Oakland.
So it kills me that we do this to ourselves. And I’m not sure that’s an accurate sentence. But I’m not sure that, “They do this to us” is more accurate. This violence against our city is gut-wrenchingly sad. I had to walk home from BART last night and I could feel the tears and residual tear gas in the air. The sadness was palpable. I was a good 10 blocks from the highest point the protesters reached.
When I say “do this to ourselves” or “done to us,” I mean this, I mean Oscar Grant. I understand why the Grant protests turned violent. (I don’t understand why they were Oakland protests and not BART protests, but that’s not relevant anymore.) The rest of the country gets to express itself. Or, if they’re booted, they’re booted peacefully, as seems to have happened in Atlanta. There are conflicting accounts of what happened (surprise!). Truthfully, I can’t construct any sort of realistic picture of how this happened. It was completely neat and organized. It was bedlam. I think the truth is closer to the second link than the first, police-sponsored story.
God, I don’t even know how to talk about this. I don’t know where to start. This is as good as anywhere. Mayor Jean Quan is out of town. OPD chief of police just quit and interim chief Howard Jordan is in charge. So where did this come from? Who was in charge? Why did they think this would go well when the authorities had no one in charge?
The protesters were told they were fine then that story changed. They had to disperse because the camp was unsafe and unsanitary. Oakland is one of the most dangerous cities in America. We kill each other all the time. We’re somewhere around 90 homicides this year. I can’t find the number right now. The closest is 80 as of September 7. There have been more since then. And an encampment of mostly peaceful people (I’m willing to capitulate that there may have been some skirmishes as cited by the city) is the concern? How can we bring in 10 cities worth of police and helicopters for this but not to stop murdering each other? It’s sad and it’s stupid.
I can’t find it now, but I read the protest camps was bean bagged and woken/disbanded fairly violently. The police say the protesters threw paint and rocks, even, at one point, a sink at the police and so they had to be gassed. It doesn’t make sense that the protesters would just start throwing things at the police if they were all just there. A coherent narrative doesn’t exist, at least not that I’ve found. And if the concern is camping, then once the camp is broken up, it’s over, isn’t it? Why continue to gas people? Four times in three hours. Tear gas so thick that @matthai (who is a reporter for SF Chronicle) says his eyes burned two blocks away. Arrested being held until at least Thursday (when arrested very early Tuesday morning) and held on $10,000 bail. The violence from above seems so disproportionate. There were also neutral accounts of police cars smashed, a store looted. But there’s a pretty big difference between violence against property and violence against people. And violence with authority and violence without authority.
It just makes me so sad. This wasn’t a dispersal. This was violence. This was an attack. This was a personal vendetta. No matter how it started, it seems to have turned into gassing people for existing downtown. It seems to have turned into not allowing any sort of assembling, whether they were marching through the streets or stationary. The encampment may be illegal, but assembling isn’t. By all accounts, what used to be the encampment is now a mess. Litter, garbage, tents, all left to avoid the gas and violence. So, good work Oakland. You obviously got what you wanted, a clean space.
This is a shitty response and I’m not sure I’ve communicated what I wanted to, but it’s my response. I wish we didn’t hate ourselves and each other so much. I wish we felt safe with our police. I wish our police felt they were part of us, not against us. They’re in the 99% too (though only barely in Oakland with the ridiculous pension plan and high wages). Do we expect violence in Oakland so this is what happens? I wish our response wasn’t always to burn ourselves to the ground.